Lately, I’ve been trying to focus on working my way through a huge stack of graphic novels that I’ve collected and either read and forgot or just haven’t read yet. Today, I want to share my thoughts on the first ten that I made it through last week. This may turn into a series of posts if I can continue to work diligently on this project.
For now, I leave a comment or two about the art, the story, and whether I plan to keep reading the series (if available).
This one wasn’t from my personal collection but from the library. I loved how the art was a blend of muted blues and greens to convey the water aspect while Mera’s bright red hair stood out brilliantly. The story was interesting in that it showed how Mera found Arthur/Aquaman and why and was well done. Overall, this one was great, and I would definitely recommend it.
I actually read this one shortly after its release in 2011, which was around the time that Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 8 was released as a graphic novel. I didn’t remember it well at all, and on reread I understood that this was because it wasn’t particularly memorable. The art stayed true to the original actresses, which was nice. But the story didn’t cover any new ground. I probably won’t go looking for any more of this series.
It felt like reading a complex Dungeons & Dragons campaign with classic character classes, a cult to defeat, undead running rampant, and other iconic bits. However, it managed to feel original, and the characters were fun to see develop. Sometimes the art style wasn’t my favorite with angles that felt too sharp and muted colors, but overall, it worked for the story. I think I will look into volume 2!
OK. This one… This one was a little weird. But in a good way. The story was compelling and I couldn’t put it down until I’d finished. The art was less complex, but that just emphasized the story rather than detracting from it. It looks like there is a second volume, but I’m on the fence about trying to track it down. Certainly, it is worth reading.
Perhaps I would have liked this one better if I was more familiar with these characters. The premise of favorite superheroes being put back into high school and following their antics is pretty ubiquitous now, so the story itself was fine. I do like the art style and the diversity of the characters. I don’t know that I will follow this title at the moment, but I’m tempted to go find the regular series for some of these characters.
With this one, I was expecting more of a fantasy theme to go with the volcano goddess in the title. That wasn’t what I got. The detailed art was rather nice, but the story didn’t work for me at all. I won’t be pursuing this one.
As a big fan of Once Upon a Time, I was thrilled that a graphic novel was being released. I remember reading it, and not caring? So I did a reread. And was disappointed. My biggest complaint is that for the four “issues” they used a different artist for each, which didn’t help convey that the story was supposed to be cohesive and not an anthology. Secondly, the Hunter wasn’t one of my favorite characters to begin with, but this backstory only reinforced what we knew from the show. I don’t think it added any new characterization.
I’m always looking for new post-apocalyptic concepts, and this one was definitely interesting. The art did a good job of showing us the stark horror that these humans face while world building without the need for a lot of exposition. I could have used a bit more explanation for what had actually happened to Earth, but I enjoyed this one.
Having not read the book that this is based on, I can’t comment on whether it’s a faithful adaptation. But the art added a youthful edge to this harsh story depicting the trials of another culture. This isn’t the type of story that I like to read in my downtime, but I would recommend it to people wanting a glimpse into the life of a Middle Eastern family.
This one didn’t grab me like I thought it would. The premise was intriguing, and I liked the mystery. Sometimes the art was more angular than rounded, which through me off. Maybe the pacing it was killed it for me, but I won’t be following up on this one either.
What do you think? Have you read any of these? I’d love to hear your thoughts and/or disagreements with my assessments.